Jewish Content   Holidays   Shabbat   Chabad-houses   Chassidism   Subscribe   Calendar   Links B"H

High-Holidays   |   Chanukah   |   Purim   |   Passover   |   Shavuot

Chanukah   |   19 Kislev   |   Chanukah-Guide Map



   
Introduction

The History of Chanukah

The Menorah Files

How to Celebrate Chanukah

Stories

Thoughts on Chanukah

Q & A

   Mikets and Chanukah

Chanukah on the 25th

Guaranteed Pure Oil

Celebrating 8 Days

Heightened Commitment

The Reasons for the Dispute

The Difference Between the Reasons

Menorah In The Courtyard

The Horn of An Ox

Festivities On The Fifth Day

The Dreidel and The Gragger

Letters From the Rebbe

Children's Corner

The Significance of Chanukah

 
 The Reasons for the Dispute Menorah In The Courtyard


The Difference Between the Reasons

"Beit Hillel says, "The first night light one and add one more each succeeding night... one given reason is that it corresponds to the days that passed... (another reason is that) in matters of holiness, one should always increase and not decrease." (Shabbat 21b)

QUESTION:

What is the halachic difference between the two approaches to explain the opinion of Beit Hillel?

ANSWER:
One difference may be as follows: When someone is extremely limited with resources, and on the second night of Chanukah lights only one candle, if on the third night he has sufficient resources, how many should he kindle?

According to those who assert that Beit Hillel's opinion is based on the days that passed, he would have to light three candles. According to the explanation that it is necessary to increase in holiness and not decrease, it would be sufficient to light only two candles, since the night before he only lit one.

Another difference would be in the event that on the third night of Chanukah one had resources sufficient only for two candles, how many should he light? If Beit Hillel's opinion follows the days that passed, in this case, since one cannot light three candles, one will light only a single candle, in order to fulfill the basic obligation of lighting a candle each night of Chanukah.

According to the other explanation, one would light two candles. Though one cannot accomplish the increase in matters of holiness, at least one will not violate the command of not to decrease in matters of holiness.

 The Reasons for the Dispute Menorah In The Courtyard



Current
  • Daily Lessons
  • Weekly Texts & Audio
  • Candle-Lighting times

    613 Commandments
  • 248 Positive
  • 365 Negative

    PDA
  • BlackBerry
  • iPhone / iPod Touch
  • Java Phones
  • Palm Pilot
  • Palm Pre
  • Pocket PC
  • P800/P900
  • Moshiach
  • Resurrection
  • For children - part 1
  • For children - part 2

    General
  • Jewish Women
  • Holiday guides
  • About Holidays
  • The Hebrew Alphabet
  • Hebrew/English Calendar
  • Glossary

    Books
  • by SIE
  • About
  • Chabad
  • The Baal Shem Tov
  • The Alter Rebbe
  • The Rebbe Maharash
  • The Previous Rebbe
  • The Rebbe
  • Mitzvah Campaign

    Children's Corner
  • Rabbi Riddle
  • Rebbetzin Riddle
  • Tzivos Hashem

  • © Copyright 1988-2009
    All Rights Reserved
    Jewish Content